Sunday, October 11, 2009

Carolina robbed at goal line??

We've got controversy at Bank of America Stadium. The Panthers were just awarded a TD on the scoreboard, only to have it taken away by an officials' ruling.

On fourth-and-goal from the 1 -- after three previous running plays from the 2 netted only 1 yard -- the Panthers tried a quick hitter with fullback Brad Hoover.

It was close. At first, there was no signal. Then, as officials scurried in, they put up the TD signal and fans rejoiced. It looked like Carolina was about to tie the game at 7-7.

But then, before the Panthers could kick the extra point to cap what had apparently been an impressive 58-yard drive (keyed mostly by Jake Delhomme's passing), the officials stopped the game and had a conference.

And the TD was waved off.

Referee Walt Coleman explained it over the microphone to the fans -- Hoover had actually fumbled the ball on the play and it had been recovered by TE Jeff King. You can't recover a "forward fumble" in the end zone, however, and so instead Washington took over inside its own 1.

Carolina challenged the ruling, but to no avail.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

The ball broke the plane of the goal line before it ever came out. Should have been a touchdown. Panthers were robbed.

Anonymous said...

it ;looked like it went over but the fact is that they never should hae given hoover the ball in that situation....i dont why they refused to do a toss play to the right on any of their chances there...im almost at tears and i blame this game on the coaching so far, good for peppers doing what he's doing, we better come out with a stop in the 2nd half and blazing on offense

Anonymous said...

it ;looked like it went over but the fact is that they never should hae given hoover the ball in that situation....i dont why they refused to do a toss play to the right on any of their chances there...im almost at tears and i blame this game on the coaching so far, good for peppers doing what he's doing, we better come out with a stop in the 2nd half and blazing on offense

Anonymous said...

I am convinced Hoover broke the goal especailly after seeing the replay at halftime of other games. What's up with the refs changing their mind before a coaches challenge.